Women’s Prize for Fiction 2020: Shortish longlist thoughts and shortlist prediction

Today we will find out the shortlist for the Women’s Prize for Fiction 2020!

First things first: I absolutely lost steam. I was powering through these books and then I wasn’t. There is no way I will finish the longlist in time for the shortlist announcement and I am very unsure if I will keep up with the project given how very much I am dreading some of the books I do not own yet and how very much I disliked a few of the books I have already read.

Overall thoughts: I find this year’s list distinctly uninspiring. I obviously have a very different taste to the judges – and while that is maybe to be expected, the degree to which I disagree what constitutes Great Fiction made this in many cases a very frustrating journey for me. For the record, what I realized while reading books that did not work for me en masse for this project was that I am looking for the following when it comes to  Literary Fiction: great prose and/or great structure, ideally coupled with interesting characters (but that is not necessary). The books on this year’s longlist are mostly told more conventionally and focus on plot and/or horrible characters. I found many themes of this year’s crop of books repetitive: there are an endless number of family sagas, often focussing on rich white families, a number of war books, many many books featuring horrible parents. Even the books I enjoyed this year are not likely to become all-time favourites of mine, unlike last year where quite a few books are still vividly both in my memory and my feelings.

As always, it was a joy to be reading this with my Women’s Prize group: Callum, Rachel, Naty, Marija, Emily (Sarah looked at the longlist and cleverly noped out right then and there). They even made the horrible experience that was reading Girl bearable because we were all in accord here. In general, we did struggle with this list a lot more than last year: of the 16 books, 6 have gotten an average rating of 3-stars or lower from us collectively, with one getting the frankly impressive low rating of 1.2 stars.

Of the books I have read so far, this is my current ranking:

  1. Actress by Anne Enright (review): 5 out of 5 stars
  2. Girl, Woman, Other by Bernardine Evaristo (review): 4.5 out of 5 stars
  3. Hamnet by Maggie O’Farrell (currently reading)
  4. Weather by Jenny Offill (review): 4 out of 5 stars
  5. A Thousand Ships by Natalie Haynes (review): 3.5 out of 5 stars
  6. Red at the Bone by Jacqueline Woodson (review): 3 out of 5 stars
  7. The Most Fun We Ever Had by Claire Lombardo (DNF)
  8. Nightingale Point by Luan Goldie (review): 2 out of 5 stars
  9. The Dutch House by Ann Patchett (review): 1.5 out of 5 stars
  10. Girl by Edna O’Brien (review): 1 out of 5 stars

Not planning on reading: The Mirror and the Light by Hilary Mantel

I have read the first few pages of Queenie by Candice Carty-Williams and did not love it (I am not very happy with its glib tone and then sudden introduction of miscarriage – but I am willing to at some point keep reading and see if that changes), and the same is true for Dominicana by Angie Cruz, which I did not hate but I cannot see giving more than 3 stars to. I do already own a copy of Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line by Deepa Anappara, so chances are I will get to it eventually.

Prediction for the shortlist:

I don’t even have properly have a wish list this year – and most weirdly, I am actively rooting for the “big name”-authors on the list which is unusual for me because I do really love a well-excecuted debut novel.

45993330Actress by Anne Enright

My favourite of the books I have read, I thought this book handled this year’s unofficial theme of motherhood the best. The narrator’s warmth towards her mother while not being blind to her weaknesses was wonderful to read. Anne Enright’s prose is excellent and the book’s nonlinear stream-of-consciousness structure worked brilliantly, especially in the impeccably narrated audiobook.

45992717The Mirror and the Light by Hilary Mantel

Maybe it is odd that I am including a book I have no interest in reading but by all accounts does Mantel achieve what she set out to do here. Her books seem to work brilliantly for people who enjoy this kind of character-focused and impeccably researched historical fiction and the reviews for this have been mostly favourable. As I have said before, I do love when authors are at the top of their games.

41081373._sy475_Girl, Woman, Other by Bernardine Evaristo

The only book I had read before the longlist announcement, this is a masterpiece that should have won the Booker Prize on its own. Evaristo’s essemble cast is masterful, her prose stunning, and this book has stayed with me since I read it. Evaristo has a lot of warmth for her characters, even those who make stupid decisions. This does feature some less-than-amazing mother figures, so there’s that (it really becomes an overwhelming theme on this longlist!).

I would be very happy if this ultimately won.

43890641._sy475_Hamnet by Maggie O’Farrell

While I am not done with the book yet, I am enjoying it a whole lot. Again, I love O’Farrell’s prose (it really often comes down to this for me apparently) and the structure works. I find the way in which she sets out to tell this story masterful and I am enjoying how on the periphery Shakespeare is for many of the scenes. It does feature a horrible mother figure, but at least we are not supposed to empathize (I don’t think).

49085800._sy475_Weather by Jenny Offill

I enjoyed this a whole lot – but I do like this kind of navel-gazy, stylized writing, even if I usually encounter it more in non-fiction than in fiction. The pervasive dread of this book becomes ever more timely, especially since whatever hell we landed in right now. I thought it was cleverly done and stripped down just enough to be perfectly, bite-sized, brilliantly done.

41439813._sy475_How We Disappeared by Jing-Jing Lee

While I have not read this book and honestly do not know if I will if it doesn’t end up being shortlisted, this seems a likely contender. Of the war novels this seems to be the more successful one and the one that tackles trauma in the most nuanced way. (aside: if Girl makes the shortlist I will riot.) It would also stop the shortlist from being frighteningly UK and US centric.

22 thoughts on “Women’s Prize for Fiction 2020: Shortish longlist thoughts and shortlist prediction

  1. YES I also said I will riot if Girl makes the shortlist. That’s the only one I would be really mad about. But I agree on all the points with you, it will be interesting to see if the shortlist can be a tad more of an inspiring choice than the longlist, but I doubt it.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. The longer I sit with the shortlist the more ok I am with it. None of the really awful books (that I have read so far but for some reason I don’t think I will hate Dominicana) made it which I am taking as a win.


    1. I cannot help but feel like I jinxed it. I did say I like books about motherhood in my predictions post and look what we got: ONLY books about motherhood. And the Mantel.


  2. It’s a bit grim, isn’t it, and dull. I wonder if there’ll be some kind of reaction against the commercialization in a few years. Hope so. We’ll have to wait and see what happens this evening. (Haven’t read Girl, but y’all are making me think that was a good call…)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I would love for the books to be a bit more experimental again. Even if I ultimately didn’t love the shortlist, last year there were some really exciting books on the longlist. And yes, Girl is all kinds of awful and you definitely made the correct decision by not reading it!


  3. feel exactly the same way about the longlist! i honestly wouldve loved to read the longlist along with everyone else, but this list was so underwhelming for me – i disliked/hated the books on there that id already read, and the rest i just had zero interest in…compared to last year’s diverse and exciting one, this year’s longlist is disappointing to say the least 😦 ill still be interested to see which book ends up winning though 👀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You absolutely made the correct choice! This year’s list was just so disappointing! I hope the judges will at least crown a worthy winner. Also, looking at some of the upcoming books releasing in the UK, next year could be really interesting so I am keeping my fingers crossed that I will fare better then.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Your guesses were so close! I would have much preferred swapping Dominicana and A Thousand Ships with Actress and How We Disappeared, so I do like your list.

    1.2 is indeed IMPRESSIVELY low! I sincerely hope we never see a WP book that can achieve a worse rating.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I was very close – which is either impressive or indicative of how many really really weak books somehow made the longlist. I am keeping my fingers crossed for next year!
      And yes, 1.2. That’s a thing that happened. In a group that rarely gives one star-ratings!

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! The list seems really have been received mostly negatively. For me it does come down to taste a lot but I also think a few of these books should not have been there…


  5. I am so irritated that How We Disappeared didn’t make the shortlist. It was my personal favorite from the longlist and I am honestly kind of ready to riot that Dominicana made it instead. I just did not think that Dominicana was a good book, even if it deals with important themes.

    I can live with the rest of the shortlist. I haven’t read Weather yet but I will definitely give it a bash now.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Selfishly I have to admit to being more interested in reading Dominicana than reading How We Disappeared, even though the latter is probably the better book. I just do not want to read any WWII novels if I can avoid it..
      I really enjoyed Weather but I can also see how it is very much right in my wheelhouse. I hope you’ll like it!


    1. Yeah, we collectively really, really hated Girl. I rarely give out proper 1 star ratings but this book just absolutely infuriated me in a way that books rarely do.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s